Where to Eat
As self-proclaimed foodies, many of our favorite memories together have been centered around fabulous meals and great cocktails. We’ve curated a list made up of our favorite spots from the Hamptons for you to enjoy, offering everything from casual bites to seaside feasts. Cheers!
-
The Beach Hunt on Main
104 Ocean Avenue, East Hampton, NY
Take views of the ocean while indulging in our favorites: Dreamy Coffee, Beach Hut Breakfast Sandwich, Acai Bowl & Ahi Tuna Tacos.
-
Hampton Chutney Co.
107 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, NY
Grab & go delicious dosas for breakfast or lunch. Don’t miss Molly’s favorite iced cardamom latte!
-
Red Horse Market
74 Montauk Highway, East Hampton, NY
The go-to spot for sandwiches, grab-and-go snacks, and any last-minute grocery needs. Perfect for stocking up before a beach day!
-
La Fondita
74 Montauk Highway, Amagansett, NY
Grab tacos to-go while sipping a cocktail (Molly's go to = spicy marg, Colin's go to = Tecaté) from El Coche next door. Menu musts: carnitas tacos and queso fundido.
-
LUNCH
1980 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY
Retro seafood shack on the highway serving Colin’s favorite buffalo calamari and a must-try lobster roll (cold only!)
-
Clam Bar
2025 Montauk Highway, Amagansett, NY
Highway-side fish shack with no frills conveniently across the street from LUNCH. Perfect for outdoor seating and fresh seafood!
-
The Montauket
88 Firestone Road, Montauk, NY
Laid back, dive bar (cigarette machine included) with unbeatable sunsets over Gardiner’s Island. Pair your view with a beer.
-
Duryea's
Boozy seafood lunches on the water! Don’t miss the infamous lobster cobb salad.
-
Inlet Seafood
541 E. Lake Drive, Montauk, NY
Fresh-off-the-boat seafood with great cocktails & fabulous views of Montauk harbor! Must orders: tuna tartar & baked clams.
-
Townline BBQ
3593 Montauk Highway, Sagaponack, NY
Mouth watering barbecue you can smell from the parking lot! Be sure to order the spicy pickles.
-
Sag Pizza
103 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY
Wood-fired pizza & seasonal cocktails. Stroll Sag Harbor before indulging in Big Olaf or Buddhaberry for dessert.
-
Big Olaf
Homemade waffle cones and generous scoops. Don’t forget—it’s cash only!